A Trip to the Magistrates’ Court
Recently in Year 10 Politics and Legal Studies we embarked on a long-awaited excursion to the Melbourne Magistrates’ Court to witness public court cases and put our understanding of judicial foundations to the test. Throughout this term, we delved into various topics such as the different types of laws and courts, fair trial rights and responsibilities, the rule of law, and even engaged in a mock trial related to “The Bachelor”! Visiting the Magistrates’ Court provided a valuable opportunity to gain firsthand experience in observing the dynamics between magistrates, the prosecution, the defence, and witnesses involved in criminal cases, particularly summary offences or minor indictable offences. Additionally, it enhanced our grasp of the language, mannerisms, and layout unique to a courtroom - it was definitely different from the ones seen on TV!
Katie (10L)
Our class gathered at the rose garden before heading off to the Magistrates’ Court after Period 1. Following a tram ride, we walked to the courts and underwent an airport-like screening process before entering. We had the privilege of meeting an esteemed court magistrate who provided insights into the role of these courts within Australia’s judicial system. The magistrate also explained to us the importance of empathy towards everyone at court, underscoring our role as fellow citizens. Our class was buzzing with questions and comments, and we got an overall impression of the implementation of law in Australia. From this, our class split into smaller groups to be able to explore a number of courtrooms that had legal proceedings. Each group presented different cases - some involving bail applications, others fines, and some delving into other matters. The gravity of each situation was palpable, and our class demonstrated a high level of maturity as audience members. We reconvened as a class for a final check-in with the magistrate, sharing our experiences and opinions before seizing the opportunity to sit in the different positions within the courtroom. Personally, I felt very important sitting in the magistrate’s seat! After leaving the courts, we stopped by for lunch close to a tram stop - discussing our day over a meal provided a moment of connection and bonding outside of the classroom setting. Overall, I speak on behalf of my entire class when I say that this excursion was both rewarding and eye-opening, and we would definitely want to visit again!
Riya (10J)
Our visit underscored the notion that the law is not an abstract, distant concept but rather directly influences the future of countless individuals. While different people may commit the same crime, the nuances of each case and the personal circumstances involved vary significantly. This highlights the crucial role of the judiciary in interpreting and applying the law on a case-by-case basis.
Joey (10J)
Personally, I thoroughly enjoyed the experience of going to the Magistrates’ Court. Witnessing different court proceedings allowed me to see snapshots (and short snapshots they were!) of different people’s lives.As the magistrate we heard from aptly put it: “You are seeing people having the worst day of their lives.” While the situations may seem ridiculous or trivial, understanding the circumstances behind them is crucial. Conversations with the magistrate and attending diverse court sessions deepened my understanding of why people commit crimes and fostered a greater appreciation for the privileges in my own life, such has having a home, attending school, and having friends. Importantly, I now recognise that the Magistrates’ Court aims not to punish the accused but to comprehend the underlying reasons for their actions, whether it be addiction, alcoholism, or a troubled home life. The court seeks to find ways to help the accused individuals address the root of the problem and improve their lives. All in all, this was an incredible and, above all, a profoundly human experience.
Abigail (10J)
Thank you to Mr Regalo for arranging this eye-opening excursion and to Mr Corr for accompanying us and sharing his own insights at the courts.